자작일기
 왕초보 게시판
 Amplifier 자작
 Speaker 자작
 Tannoy Westminster
 기타 자작
 Utility/Tip
 LP 이야기
 나의 Audio
   
   
 
작성일 : 06-02-20 11:49
[막가표 발판 시리즈(2) 2A3/45] Operating Point for Triode
 글쓴이 :
조회 : 1,228  
(Presumably the question was, "How do you figure out the correct operating point for a triode?")

Perhaps surprisingly, that's not a really easy question to answer. I've been playing with the theory part of the question (with only slight forays into the subjective sonics part) for several years now. I'll try to get you started though.

First, I think it's important to include load impedance as well as plate current and plate-to-cathode voltage in what we call "operating point", at least for circuits where the output signal is a large fraction of the quiescent voltage or current.

I'll restrict the rest of this to triodes with resistive loads, to keep it simple.

The specs will give a maximum plate voltage, dissipation, and current. You'll have to stay within these limits or risk a shortened tube life. Operating well below the maximums will increase life somewhat but reduce available power, voltage, or current - a good trade for preamps but not power amps, in general.

The parameter I find most useful is the "operating resistance", plate voltage divided by current. It must be larger than 1.5 times the plate resistance if the grid is to be kept negative, and in practice a minimum of about 3 times plate resistance is desirable. For tubes that are not very linear, a low value (such as 3) for this ratio will keep the operation in the high current area where distortion is relatively low.

Highly linear tubes are less prone to distortion at high voltage and low current. A higher ratio of operating resistance to plate resistance will increase the available output voltage and power efficiency. The disadvantages are reduced current drive available, and a higher impedance load (more susceptible to capacitive problems such as loss of highs, RF pickup, etc). A very linear tube such as a 300B may be operated at a ratio as high as 10, but 5 to 6 is usually as high as you want to go with most tubes.

Once you've chosen your operating voltage and current, you need to find a load impedance. A good approximation is the operating resistance minus 2.4 times the plate resistance. I derived this in a 3-part article in VALVE; I won't try to cram the math into this post though!

You can look up the bias on the plate curves. There's a formula but it's not simple. A rough estimate for the cathode bias resistor is load impedance divided by mu.

Paul Joppa

폴자파와 이메일 토론에 있던 글 퍼왔심다

요약

1. operating resistance(OR) = plate voltage(Va) / current(Ia)

2. OR must be larger than 1.5 times the plate resistance and in practice a minimum of about 3 times plate resistance is desirable

3. A very linear tube such as a 300B may be operated at a ratio as high as 10, but 5 to 6 is usually as high as with most tubes.

4. A good approximation is the operating resistance minus 2.4 times the plate resistance

5. A rough estimate for the cathode bias resistor is load impedance divided by mu




J 06-02-20 13:44
 
  3극/5극에 관계없이 로드저항이 rp보다 굉장히 작으면 특성의 기복이 심한듯합니다.
특히 저역에 문제가 있을듯....
06-02-20 13:53
 
  이사람의 논지는 항상 전류를 많이 흘리는 것이 다 좋은 것은 아니다는 같심다.

로드에 관해서는 아는 것이 없심다

적어면 왜곡이 많고, 많으면 게인도 증가하고 왜곡이 주는데 손해를 보는 면이 있지 않을까요?

"No Freelunch" 혹은" Everything pays for it" 이런말이 있는 것 처럼
. 06-02-20 13:54
 
  로드가 적어면 Zo이 감소하는 효과가 있겠네요.
얼빵이사 06-02-20 14:01
 
  트랜스프리를 만들면서 경험한것인데...
rp 의 2~3배 가 저역특성이 더좋았으며....
전류는 많이 흘려야 열만 나고 그리 특성이 좋아지지는
않는것 같읍니다..
모찌 06-02-20 15:13
 
  관에 흘리는 전류는 Rp를 변화시키기 때문에 로드저항값도  조정해주어야 합니다.
전류를 많이 흘려서 혹은 적게 흘려서 어느쪽이 더 좋다기 보다 관이외의 부품정수는
값이 정해져있는데 관만 전류값을 조절하면 소리는 당연히 달라지는거죠.

 
 

Total 3,679
번호 제         목               글쓴이            날짜 조회
3364 [막가표 발판 시리즈(2) 2A3/45] Operating Point for Triode (5) 06-02-20 1229
3363 [자작] 역시 또 다른 pre amp를 만들어야 할 처지_03 ( 저는 일 안하고 싱겁게 마무리 ) (2) 허브 19-12-03 1229
3362    [자작] 노이만(WV2) 회로도 허브 20-02-14 1230
3361    [자작] [re] 5극 프리에의 도전... J 05-10-27 1230
3360 [질문] WE418A 질문 드립니다. (2) 무시나 07-07-02 1230
3359    [자작] [re] 중생님 보십시요 (1) 권기창 06-02-19 1231
3358          [질문] [re] 두번째 수수께끼 -(사진) (3) 素心 08-12-02 1231
3357       [자작] 프리+파워 중생 05-09-22 1232
3356 [질문] 모찌스 프리에 적용하는 회로도 한 부탁드립니다. (1) 케디스 05-10-11 1232
3355 [자작] 저항공구 관련 공지 (3) 함해봐 05-01-23 1233
3354    [자작] [re] 만약 여기 초단과 드라이버단에 션트레귤레이션관을 넣는다면... (1) 새잡이 05-02-18 1233
3353       [막가표 발판 시리즈(2) 2A3/45] [re] 한단 앰프.. (10) J 05-10-17 1233
3352 [막가표 발판 시리즈(2) 2A3/45] 새로 설계한 6DJ8 pre 전원부 (5) 06-11-07 1233
3351 [자작] 누가 룬달 1674 트랜스 싸게 주실 분 계신가요? (4) 새잡이 05-01-20 1234
3350    [자작] [re] 프리와 파워 (4) 함해봐 05-02-12 1234
   16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30    

배너광고/월 15만원
Copyright ⓒ 2002~2022 Simpletube.com All rights reserved. Powered by Simpletube
[이메일 무단 수집거부]와 [개인정보 보호방침](입금계좌 농협 578-02-035576 김용민)
꼼방 운영자 허브 hub004@gmail.com